Skip to main content
3 min read

Your essential guide to improve the quality of job applications you receive

In today’s competitive UK hiring market, the volume of applications is at an all-time high, but quality remains the biggest challenge. According to our latest research with over 624 recruiters and 1,009 jobseekers, only 30% of recruiters say they received high-quality applications during their most recent hiring process.

Close-up of a business meeting, with one person holding and pointing at a printed document clipped to a folder. Other participants are seated around the table, with laptops, pens, and takeaway coffee cups visible. The focus is on the discussion of the document, with hands and paperwork in the foreground.

Key findings from the research: defining application quality

  • Less than 1 in 3 recruiters receive high-quality applications.
  • 50% of applications fail to make it past the first screening stage.
  • 70% of recruiters reject candidates for lacking relevant skills.
  • 69% of jobseekers find job descriptions unclear.
  • 74% of recruiters believe AI improves application quality but reduces authenticity.

High-quality applications are defined by:

  • Relevant skills and experience.
  • Clear, well-structured, and formatted documents.
  • Accurate alignment with role requirements.

The four pillars of application quality

1. Writing clear, inclusive job descriptions

  • Use jargon-free, searchable titles.
  • Separate essential from desirable qualifications.
  • Include salary ranges and flexible working options.
  • Highlight company values and growth opportunities.
A woman with curly red hair working at a desk in a bright, modern office. She is typing on a wireless keyboard, with a laptop placed on a stand in front of her. The desk also holds a mouse, tablet, notebook, and a glass of water. Colourful sticky notes are visible on the glass wall in the background.
How to write job requirements that attract top talent 

Attracting the right candidates starts with writing job requirements that are clear, realistic, and appealing.

However, data from the latest Totaljobs research reveals that less than one in three recruiters receive high-quality applications for their most recent hire.

With hiring costs and competition for talent at record highs, getting your job requirements right is more important than ever.

2. Smart pre-screening and assessment tools

  • Deploy structured pre-screening questions.
  • Use skill-based assessments early in the process.
  • Balance automation with human review.
A smartly dressed man sits at a wooden table in a modern indoor setting, reviewing documents held in a blue folder. He appears focused, with a pen in hand. On the table are a cup of coffee, a glass of water, a notebook, and a smartphone. Lush green plants can be seen in the background.
The only 20 pre-screening questions you’ll ever need to hire smarter

Effective pre-screening is the secret weapon of efficient, high-quality hiring. According to new research from Totaljobs, 50% of applications don’t make it past the first hiring stage, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing.

3. Objective interview processes

  • Train interviewers on bias awareness.
  • Implement structured interviews with scoring rubrics.
  • Focus on competency-based evaluation.
A group of five colleagues gathered around a high desk in a modern office, engaged in discussion. Two women are seated, one of whom is pointing at a laptop screen, while the others stand or lean in attentively. Notebooks, a tablet, and a takeaway coffee cup are on the desk. The office space features glass walls and a bright, open layout.
How to objectively assess interviews every time

Interviews remain the cornerstone of hiring decisions, yet they are also among the most subjective stages of the recruitment process. Bias, inconsistencies, and “gut feelings” often creep in, leading to poor hiring outcomes.

As competition for top talent grows fiercer and diversity goals sharpen, learning how to objectively assess interviews is no longer optional. It’s essential.

4. Leveraging technology without losing the human touch

  • Use AI-powered ATS tools for efficient shortlisting.
  • Supplement AI decisions with human insight.
  • Audit AI systems regularly for fairness and effectiveness.
A man sitting at a desk in an office, reaching out to take a printed document from a woman seated across from him. The workspace features dual curved monitors, a keyboard, various stationery items, a small potted plant, and a large window letting in natural light. The woman holds a pen and appears to be explaining something.
7 ways AI is changing the hiring process in 2025 (and how to stay human)

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is no longer the future — it’s already firmly part of the hiring process.

In 2025, AI tools are integrated across the recruitment journey, making hiring faster, more data-driven, and often more efficient. On average, recruiters estimate that 41% of applications have been enhanced by AI tools, from CV optimisation to automated assessments.

But while these innovations bring clear advantages, they also introduce new risks, especially around authenticity, fairness, and over-reliance on technology.

Common pitfalls that undermine application quality

  • Overly complex or lengthy application processes.
  • Excessive focus on ‘perfect’ candidate profiles.
  • Inflexible screening criteria that exclude non-traditional candidates.
  • Poor communication and lack of feedback.
  • Simplify the application process: Use mobile-friendly, auto-fill enabled forms. Be transparent: Share salary details and hiring timelines upfront.
  • Focus on potential: Value transferable skills and soft skills.
  • Review and refine: Regularly audit your job ads, screening methods, and interview processes.
  • Invest in training: Equip your hiring team with tools and training on bias reduction and objective evaluation.

How candidates are adapting: the rise of ai-tailored applications

  • 67% of jobseekers use AI to tailor CVs.
  • 65% use AI to generate or refine cover letters.
  • Despite polish, authenticity remains crucial, focus interviews on real experience.

Why quality over quantity wins

In the race for top talent, volume alone will not deliver the right hire. A quality-first strategy reduces time-to-hire, enhances candidate experience, and leads to stronger, longer-lasting hires. By refining your approach at every stage of the recruitment funnel, you can unlock better outcomes for both candidates and your organisation.

Download the complete How to improve the quality of job applications you receive report for more insights and tools to help you hire smarter in 2025.

WAS THIS HELPFUL?